@CloudExpo Authors: Zakia Bouachraoui, Yeshim Deniz, Liz McMillan, Pat Romanski, Elizabeth White

Related Topics: @CloudExpo, Containers Expo Blog

@CloudExpo: Blog Feed Post

VDI or Cloudtop Computing?

Virtualization is one of those things that has kept IT shops humming over the last few years


There are two interesting and complimentary rules in IT

  1. When a technology takes off, vendors will keep trying to find “the next big thing” to earn more of your business.
  2. Until something takes off, most IT staff doesn’t have time to worry about it.

Virtualization is one of those things that has kept IT shops humming over the last few… several… Many years. When it first came out I was in an R&D group at a mid-sized company, and from that perspective was able to grasp the early adopter use case and run with it. That use case is still one of the primary drivers for virtualization in the data center, though it is growing less important as other uses come to the fore – that was consolidation of underutilized servers, which enterprises had a lot of, because budgeting was by project and Larry Ellison’s famous “Lots of little servers” comment had become IT staff’s very real nightmare.


No sooner had IT departments found a solid way to put virtualized servers to work than vendors started creating/rebranding/vaporizing The Next Big Thing. I played with a virtualized firewall long before any IT person saw a need for one, storage virtualization got a shot in the arm and vendors started pushing it in their talks – and how it helped server virtualization, everything was going to be virtualized… and one day may well be.

And one of the things that vendors jumped on that IT just hasn’t really bought yet is Virtualized Desktops. Vendors hype it, they pay analyst firms for quotes about the wave of the future, but you don’t see 10 bazillion enterprises running Virtual Desktops. Does that mean Virtual Desktop Infrastructure (VDI) is a failure? Not. Quite. Yet.

There is an interesting bit where the changing infrastructure of today sometimes points the way to the technologies of tomorrow. Apple’s change to BSD and the ensuing release of all sorts of devices running the “Apple” OS as iSOMETHING is a good example of that phenomenon. That may be what we’re going to see with VDI.


If a large portion of your infrastructure moves to the cloud (and by cloud I mean internal or external, just so you know how I’m using the term), then you will have a lot of apps that can be accessed via web browser. Some entire groups may be able to move to the browser for all but a few categories of work. In the case of external cloud, I don’t think we’re to the point where you could save next year’s business plan out to the cloud and rest assured that it was as secure as in your data center. There are those who would argue with me, but I’m guessing none of them are security peeps.

That means that for some groups in some organizations there will soon only be limited need of internal systems. If your need for compute power is dropping per-user because it has been shifted to a need “in the cloud”, then it starts to make sense to take the next logical step and virtualize those people’s desktops so that when they ARE running a fat app, it’s not on their machine. Why would you  do that? Well, I think that VMWare has done a good job of showing the benefits in terms of security and compliance with software licensing, I haven’t seen anyone talk about the benefits to managing the flow of hardware. Want a Mac? Cool, we no longer have to maintain software on it, just AV and VDI client. I think that’s a bigger benefit than is immediately obvious, adding a desktop OS means a whole lot of work to make sure all the apps run on it, but it doesn’t mean that if your desktops are virtualized.

And using VDI for remote workers means no more work installing and updating desktops and laptops all over the world. Run updates in the data center, and they’ll get them next time they log in.


Looking into the crystal ball, I see three distinct groups falling out of this. Those who can be 100% cloud applications, those who can make use of VDI for the few applications they need on the desktop, and thoseVDI.With.Cloud who still require a fat desktop. Let’s look at how to figure this bit out.

  • Cloudtop – those whose systems have been moved to the cloud, that don’t have sensitive documents to work on (assuming public cloud) and don’t do a ton of traveling.
  • Virtual Desktop – those who have a few apps in the cloud but still need to get at some legacy applications, or those who need to work on sensitive materials with an external cloud provider.
  • Fat Desktop – those who need to do a lot of really intensive drawing work (architects with AutoCAD for example) or those who travel a lot. This is also the default, since everyone is here today.

There’s always something though. If you’re going to implement cloudtop computing or virtual desktop infrastructure, you’ll need to have a fat pipe out of your data center. Let’s face it, this is mostly traffic over and above what you’re seeing today. For every document saved to the network there is at least one that never leaves the local hard disk. The same is true for most other computing needs. In a VDI infrastructure, ALT-TAB carries a network burden, for example. For employees on the same physical network as the virtual servers or internal cloud, this is not a big deal unless your network is already near maxed out. For remote employees – even at another company office – it starts to become a burden on the infrastructure. Products like F5’s WOM or EDGE Gateway can go a long way to resolving these issues, but you do need to consider them before implementing.


And maybe that’s why there aren’t a ton of enterprises that have moved to virtual desktops. You can’t know what the network impacts are until you try it full-bore, and at that point you’ve paid for the project, so can you rightfully go back? That is probably making more enterprises skittish than the perception that we all need our own fat desktop. Well, that and the odd issue. I’m a remote worker, but I would still need full USB support and ability to browse from my laptop so that I could upload images I take in the line of duty. This need already reduces the potential savings to my employer of putting me on a truly thin client.

As you can see, the future in this space is still pretty undecided. I think it would be cool to have one largish enterprise – say larger mid-size – completely virtualize desktops and then tell us all how it went, three months, six months, and a year into the deployment. That’s probably what it will take to truly spark interest, perhaps VDI vendors like VMWare and Microsoft should consider sponsoring such a project.


My personal opinion? That it is a non-starter. That’s a very gut reaction subject to change based upon all of the above, but imagine not having access to your work laptop or desktop because it was replaced with something smaller and slower, and the apps ran from the network. Not some apps, all of them. Network connectivity would be a constant concern, doing without local apps would be a pain… And we’re spoiled. The natural conclusion when you  think about it for a while is “well… I could, but that’s really a niche space for someone else…” Except if we all think it’s for someone else, then it’s not viable, now is it?

But I’ve been wrong before, and as I alluded to above, one solid mid-sized company with a huge success story could change the equation entirely. I just don’t know how, at the current cost of laptops and desktops, you can reap the savings of ROI. Though the peace of mind that you know what apps your users have installed is appealing, that’s not ROI, it’s risk avoidance.

More Stories By Don MacVittie

Don MacVittie is founder of Ingrained Technology, A technical advocacy and software development consultancy. He has experience in application development, architecture, infrastructure, technical writing,DevOps, and IT management. MacVittie holds a B.S. in Computer Science from Northern Michigan University, and an M.S. in Computer Science from Nova Southeastern University.

CloudEXPO Stories
Having been in the web hosting industry since 2002, dhosting has gained a great deal of experience while working on a wide range of projects. This experience has enabled the company to develop our amazing new product, which they are now excited to present! Among dHosting's greatest achievements, they can include the development of their own hosting panel, the building of their fully redundant server system, and the creation of dhHosting's unique product, Dynamic Edge.
Your job is mostly boring. Many of the IT operations tasks you perform on a day-to-day basis are repetitive and dull. Utilizing automation can improve your work life, automating away the drudgery and embracing the passion for technology that got you started in the first place. In this presentation, I'll talk about what automation is, and how to approach implementing it in the context of IT Operations. Ned will discuss keys to success in the long term and include practical real-world examples. Get started on automating your way to a brighter future!
The challenges of aggregating data from consumer-oriented devices, such as wearable technologies and smart thermostats, are fairly well-understood. However, there are a new set of challenges for IoT devices that generate megabytes or gigabytes of data per second. Certainly, the infrastructure will have to change, as those volumes of data will likely overwhelm the available bandwidth for aggregating the data into a central repository. Ochandarena discusses a whole new way to think about your next-gen applications and how to address the challenges of building applications that harness all data types and sources.
DXWorldEXPO LLC announced today that Big Data Federation to Exhibit at the 22nd International CloudEXPO, colocated with DevOpsSUMMIT and DXWorldEXPO, November 12-13, 2018 in New York City. Big Data Federation, Inc. develops and applies artificial intelligence to predict financial and economic events that matter. The company uncovers patterns and precise drivers of performance and outcomes with the aid of machine-learning algorithms, big data, and fundamental analysis. Their products are deployed by some of the world's largest financial institutions. The company develops and applies innovative machine-learning technologies to big data to predict financial, economic, and world events. The team is a group of passionate technologists, mathematicians, data scientists and programmers in Silicon Valley with over 100 patents to their names. Big Data Federation was incorporated in 2015 and is ...
Dynatrace is an application performance management software company with products for the information technology departments and digital business owners of medium and large businesses. Building the Future of Monitoring with Artificial Intelligence. Today we can collect lots and lots of performance data. We build beautiful dashboards and even have fancy query languages to access and transform the data. Still performance data is a secret language only a couple of people understand. The more business becomes digital the more stakeholders are interested in this data including how it relates to business. Some of these people have never used a monitoring tool before. They have a question on their mind like "How is my application doing" but no idea how to get a proper answer.