Welcome!

@CloudExpo Authors: Ed Featherston, Rostyslav Demush, Jamie Madison, Jason Bloomberg, Greg Pierce

Related Topics: @CloudExpo, Industrial IoT, Microservices Expo, Agile Computing, Release Management , Cloud Security

@CloudExpo: Article

Don’t Let Your Hybrid Cloud Collapse into a Black Hole

A PMTUD black hole can cause a particularly subtle set of issues in hybrid cloud-based environments

A PMTUD black hole can cause a particularly subtle set of issues in hybrid cloud-based environments where the cloud resources are connected to a corporate office or other datacenter via IPSec tunnels. PMTUD black holes basically cause certain (but not all) traffic to not make it through the tunnel.

PMTUD Overview
Before we get down and dirty into the problems with PMTUD, let's quickly go over what PMTUD is.

PMTUD stands for Path Maximum Transmission Unit Discovery and it is a protocol/algorithm defined in RFC 1191 that determines the best packet size for IPv4 datagrams flowing between any two given hosts. In this way, it attempts to optimize traffic through the Internet by using the largest possible datagram that doesn't require intermediary routers to fragment the traffic (since fragmentation and, more importantly, reassembly are expensive operations for routers to perform).

It works like this ... if I'm a host (say an FTP server) who wants to send the largest packet I possibly can to another host (say an FTP client), I will start with what I know, which is the maximum transmission unit (MTU) of my underlying ethernet interface (normally 1500 bytes). I will then send this packet out with the Don't Fragment (DF) bit set in the IPv4 header. If a router in the path would need to fragment this packet in order to send it along to the next hop (because its outbound interface was, say 1450 bytes), it will send back an Internet Control Message Protocol (ICMP) reply indicating that fragmentation was needed, but the DF bit was set. The implication is that the packet was dropped. In this ICMP reply, it also specifies what the MTU should be (in this case 1450 bytes). The originating host will then resend a packet of this size. This can happen multiple times if, for example, another router later on down the path has an even smaller MTU on its outbound interface. Eventually the packet gets to the destination host using a size that is the most optimal for the path and all subsequent 'large' packets will also be this optimal size.

Nowadays, PMTUD often comes into play when we're talking about tunneling traffic. Since tunnels require that some extra headers be inserted, they have an effective MTU that is the original ethernet MTU less the size of the additional headers.

The Problem with PMTUD
There are a few common causes for not being able to get the ICMP replies necessary for PMTUD to work. Overzealous network administrators will configure their firewalls to drop all ICMP since certain ICMP messages are considered security threats. Routers are sometimes (mis) configured with PMTUD disabled and so will simply drop the packet without sending the required ICMP message.

As we can see, the ICMP messages that PMTUD requires to work can be kept from the originating host due to various factors beyond the host's control, and often beyond the control of even the network administrators responsible for the network to which the host is directly attached.

What's the problem with PMTUD. The real problem with PMTUD is that it fails closed. This is anathema to the Robustness Principle, and it is a well understood problem by the Internet Engineering Task Force (IETF) as evidenced by RFC 2923:

"PMTUD, as documented in RFC 1191, fails when the appropriate ICMP messages are not received by the originating host. The upper-layer protocol continues to try to send large packets and, without the ICMP messages, never discovers that it needs to reduce the size of those packets. Its packets are disappearing into a PMTUD black hole."

The most common symptom of hitting a PMTUD black hole is that some, but not all traffic seems to make it between hosts. A Transmission Control Protocol (TCP) connection may be established for a file transfer and then stall out. If the ICMP messages are only being dropped in one direction, the same file transfer in the other direction might work just fine.

RFC 1191 doesn't speak to what the host implementation should do if it fails to receive protocol packets. It leaves that as an exercise to the upper layer protocol implementor. Is this the fault of the RFC 1191 contributors? Probably. They should have dictated that, by default, when exceeding an implementation specific timeout, upper layer protocols must cease to set the DF bit in packets that they send.

RFC 2923 basically says as much by suggesting that TCP do this as a fix for the issue:

"TCP should notice that the connection is timing out. After several timeouts, TCP should attempt to send smaller packets, perhaps turning off the DF flag for each packet."

IPv6 takes the problem completely out of the hands of the routers by failing hard open. Again, from RFC 2923:

"Note that, under IPv6, there is no DF bit-it is implicitly on at all times. Fragmentation is not allowed in routers, only at the originating host. Fortunately, the minimum supported MTU for IPv6 is 1280 octets, which is significantly larger than the 68 octet minimum in IPv4. This should make it more reasonable for IPv6 TCP implementations to fall back to 1280 octet packets, when IPv4 implementations will probably have to turn off DF to respond to black hole detection."

RFC 2923 opines that:

"This creates a market disincentive for deploying TCP implementation with PMTUD enabled."

However, host networking stacks did implement PMTUD, but allowed it to fail closed. Since RFC 2923, host networking stacks have implemented variations of its suggestions. The Linux networking stack, as of 2.6.17 mainline, implemented TCP MTU probing described in RFC 4821, although it is not enabled by default. The Windows networking stack has implemented PMTUD black hole detection, and recently made it the default in Win2k8, Vista, Windows 7, and Windows 8.

Solutions
This leaves us still living with PMTUD black holes. I often see this when we connect our cloud networks, via an IPSec VPN, to our customer's corporate networks. Many of these customer networks are large and managed by various different groups; often there is a router or firewall that blocks all ICMP or simply doesn't participate in PMTUD. The hosts tend to be heterogenous, consisting of various versions of Windows and different *NIXs and so some of them will detect PMTUD black holes and others won't. This makes debugging difficult.

As a workaround, routers and tunnel endpoints have implemented MSS (Maximum Segment Size) clamping, which utilizes a part of TCP whereby the largest acceptable payload size (the MSS) is exported to the remote TCP connection endpoint as an option during the TCP connection handshake. The MSS is orthoganally bidirectional, meaning the MSS for one half of the connection can be different than the MSS of the other.

Normally the MSS is set by the originating host based on the MTU of its outbound interface. However, an intermediary router/firewall can modify the MSS based on the knowledge it has about the MTU of its interfaces. If the destination interface is one that has an MTU too small for the MSS it sees in the TCP SYN packet, it will rewrite the MSS option. In this way, intermediary routers attempt to fix PMTUD issues for TCP connections.

TL;DR
In summary, PMTUD is a protocol for discovering the maximum size of a packet you can send along a path between two hosts. It is fragile since it relies on the intermediary routers to send back information about this maximum size. If those informational packets are dropped along the way, the maximum packet size will be unknown and any traffic that exceeds it will fall into a PMTUD black hole. This means something like a file transfer or large content deliveries from web servers will fail or hang, but your ssh session and small web pages work just fine.

If you suspect that you might be the victim of a PMTUD black hole, the easiest way to validate this is by forcing the MTU of the failing host down to some relatively low value like 1300. Doing so will cause TCP to negotiate an MSS appropriate to that size. Retry your failing file transfer (or other network operation), and if it succeeds, you most likely have hit a PMTUD black hole. At this point, it's best to get your network administrator involved to help track down exactly where the black hole is, whether it can be fixed or not, and whether or not there is a router between the two networks that supports MSS clamping to work around the issue.

More Stories By Pete Holland

Pete Holland is a Software Architect with the Skytap Networking team, responsible for the design and development of the customer edge network and gateway sub-systems. He is particularly interested in the challenges presented by networks in a cloud environment and emerging technologies that address them.

Comments (0)

Share your thoughts on this story.

Add your comment
You must be signed in to add a comment. Sign-in | Register

In accordance with our Comment Policy, we encourage comments that are on topic, relevant and to-the-point. We will remove comments that include profanity, personal attacks, racial slurs, threats of violence, or other inappropriate material that violates our Terms and Conditions, and will block users who make repeated violations. We ask all readers to expect diversity of opinion and to treat one another with dignity and respect.


@CloudExpo Stories
DX World EXPO, LLC, a Lighthouse Point, Florida-based startup trade show producer and the creator of "DXWorldEXPO® - Digital Transformation Conference & Expo" has announced its executive management team. The team is headed by Levent Selamoglu, who has been named CEO. "Now is the time for a truly global DX event, to bring together the leading minds from the technology world in a conversation about Digital Transformation," he said in making the announcement.
"Space Monkey by Vivent Smart Home is a product that is a distributed cloud-based edge storage network. Vivent Smart Home, our parent company, is a smart home provider that places a lot of hard drives across homes in North America," explained JT Olds, Director of Engineering, and Brandon Crowfeather, Product Manager, at Vivint Smart Home, in this SYS-CON.tv interview at @ThingsExpo, held Oct 31 – Nov 2, 2017, at the Santa Clara Convention Center in Santa Clara, CA.
SYS-CON Events announced today that Conference Guru has been named “Media Sponsor” of the 22nd International Cloud Expo, which will take place on June 5-7, 2018, at the Javits Center in New York, NY. A valuable conference experience generates new contacts, sales leads, potential strategic partners and potential investors; helps gather competitive intelligence and even provides inspiration for new products and services. Conference Guru works with conference organizers to pass great deals to gre...
DevOps is under attack because developers don’t want to mess with infrastructure. They will happily own their code into production, but want to use platforms instead of raw automation. That’s changing the landscape that we understand as DevOps with both architecture concepts (CloudNative) and process redefinition (SRE). Rob Hirschfeld’s recent work in Kubernetes operations has led to the conclusion that containers and related platforms have changed the way we should be thinking about DevOps and...
In his Opening Keynote at 21st Cloud Expo, John Considine, General Manager of IBM Cloud Infrastructure, led attendees through the exciting evolution of the cloud. He looked at this major disruption from the perspective of technology, business models, and what this means for enterprises of all sizes. John Considine is General Manager of Cloud Infrastructure Services at IBM. In that role he is responsible for leading IBM’s public cloud infrastructure including strategy, development, and offering m...
The next XaaS is CICDaaS. Why? Because CICD saves developers a huge amount of time. CD is an especially great option for projects that require multiple and frequent contributions to be integrated. But… securing CICD best practices is an emerging, essential, yet little understood practice for DevOps teams and their Cloud Service Providers. The only way to get CICD to work in a highly secure environment takes collaboration, patience and persistence. Building CICD in the cloud requires rigorous ar...
Companies are harnessing data in ways we once associated with science fiction. Analysts have access to a plethora of visualization and reporting tools, but considering the vast amount of data businesses collect and limitations of CPUs, end users are forced to design their structures and systems with limitations. Until now. As the cloud toolkit to analyze data has evolved, GPUs have stepped in to massively parallel SQL, visualization and machine learning.
"Evatronix provides design services to companies that need to integrate the IoT technology in their products but they don't necessarily have the expertise, knowledge and design team to do so," explained Adam Morawiec, VP of Business Development at Evatronix, in this SYS-CON.tv interview at @ThingsExpo, held Oct 31 – Nov 2, 2017, at the Santa Clara Convention Center in Santa Clara, CA.
To get the most out of their data, successful companies are not focusing on queries and data lakes, they are actively integrating analytics into their operations with a data-first application development approach. Real-time adjustments to improve revenues, reduce costs, or mitigate risk rely on applications that minimize latency on a variety of data sources. In his session at @BigDataExpo, Jack Norris, Senior Vice President, Data and Applications at MapR Technologies, reviewed best practices to ...
"ZeroStack is a startup in Silicon Valley. We're solving a very interesting problem around bringing public cloud convenience with private cloud control for enterprises and mid-size companies," explained Kamesh Pemmaraju, VP of Product Management at ZeroStack, in this SYS-CON.tv interview at 21st Cloud Expo, held Oct 31 – Nov 2, 2017, at the Santa Clara Convention Center in Santa Clara, CA.
Large industrial manufacturing organizations are adopting the agile principles of cloud software companies. The industrial manufacturing development process has not scaled over time. Now that design CAD teams are geographically distributed, centralizing their work is key. With large multi-gigabyte projects, outdated tools have stifled industrial team agility, time-to-market milestones, and impacted P&L stakeholders.
Enterprises are adopting Kubernetes to accelerate the development and the delivery of cloud-native applications. However, sharing a Kubernetes cluster between members of the same team can be challenging. And, sharing clusters across multiple teams is even harder. Kubernetes offers several constructs to help implement segmentation and isolation. However, these primitives can be complex to understand and apply. As a result, it’s becoming common for enterprises to end up with several clusters. Thi...
"Infoblox does DNS, DHCP and IP address management for not only enterprise networks but cloud networks as well. Customers are looking for a single platform that can extend not only in their private enterprise environment but private cloud, public cloud, tracking all the IP space and everything that is going on in that environment," explained Steve Salo, Principal Systems Engineer at Infoblox, in this SYS-CON.tv interview at 21st Cloud Expo, held Oct 31 – Nov 2, 2017, at the Santa Clara Conventio...
In his session at 21st Cloud Expo, James Henry, Co-CEO/CTO of Calgary Scientific Inc., introduced you to the challenges, solutions and benefits of training AI systems to solve visual problems with an emphasis on improving AIs with continuous training in the field. He explored applications in several industries and discussed technologies that allow the deployment of advanced visualization solutions to the cloud.
The question before companies today is not whether to become intelligent, it’s a question of how and how fast. The key is to adopt and deploy an intelligent application strategy while simultaneously preparing to scale that intelligence. In her session at 21st Cloud Expo, Sangeeta Chakraborty, Chief Customer Officer at Ayasdi, provided a tactical framework to become a truly intelligent enterprise, including how to identify the right applications for AI, how to build a Center of Excellence to oper...
"IBM is really all in on blockchain. We take a look at sort of the history of blockchain ledger technologies. It started out with bitcoin, Ethereum, and IBM evaluated these particular blockchain technologies and found they were anonymous and permissionless and that many companies were looking for permissioned blockchain," stated René Bostic, Technical VP of the IBM Cloud Unit in North America, in this SYS-CON.tv interview at 21st Cloud Expo, held Oct 31 – Nov 2, 2017, at the Santa Clara Conventi...
In his session at 21st Cloud Expo, Carl J. Levine, Senior Technical Evangelist for NS1, will objectively discuss how DNS is used to solve Digital Transformation challenges in large SaaS applications, CDNs, AdTech platforms, and other demanding use cases. Carl J. Levine is the Senior Technical Evangelist for NS1. A veteran of the Internet Infrastructure space, he has over a decade of experience with startups, networking protocols and Internet infrastructure, combined with the unique ability to it...
22nd International Cloud Expo, taking place June 5-7, 2018, at the Javits Center in New York City, NY, and co-located with the 1st DXWorld Expo will feature technical sessions from a rock star conference faculty and the leading industry players in the world. Cloud computing is now being embraced by a majority of enterprises of all sizes. Yesterday's debate about public vs. private has transformed into the reality of hybrid cloud: a recent survey shows that 74% of enterprises have a hybrid cloud ...
"Cloud Academy is an enterprise training platform for the cloud, specifically public clouds. We offer guided learning experiences on AWS, Azure, Google Cloud and all the surrounding methodologies and technologies that you need to know and your teams need to know in order to leverage the full benefits of the cloud," explained Alex Brower, VP of Marketing at Cloud Academy, in this SYS-CON.tv interview at 21st Cloud Expo, held Oct 31 – Nov 2, 2017, at the Santa Clara Convention Center in Santa Clar...
Gemini is Yahoo’s native and search advertising platform. To ensure the quality of a complex distributed system that spans multiple products and components and across various desktop websites and mobile app and web experiences – both Yahoo owned and operated and third-party syndication (supply), with complex interaction with more than a billion users and numerous advertisers globally (demand) – it becomes imperative to automate a set of end-to-end tests 24x7 to detect bugs and regression. In th...